|
Anthropological Analysis of the Late Roman/Early Medieval Cemetery of
Novigrad (Istria) by Petra Rajić (Institute for Anthropological Research, Zagreb, Croatia)
and
Željko Ujčić (Archaeological Museum of Istria, Pula, Croatia)
Abstract
The paper presents results of analysis of human skeletal remains
recovered from Late Roman/Early Medieval cemetery of Novigrad (Istria).
The »terminus post quem« for the site was established archaeologically as
5th or 6th century A.D. The aim of this work was detailed
bioarchaeological analysis of each individual. It included determination
of sex, age at the time of death, reconstruction of body height, and
detailed description of pathological changes on bones and joint surfaces
acquired during lifetime. The analysis provides limited information on
demography, health and disease of the ancient inhabitants of Novigrad due
to the limited sample size. Results show unusually high proportion of
subadults, a life span range of women slightly lower compared to other
contemporary populations, a high level of metabolic stress in childhood
and a high level of skeletal indicators of physical stress suggesting that
several of the analyzed individuals were exposed to heavy physical labor
during their adulthood.
ANTROPOLOŠKA ANALIZA OSTEOLOŠKOG MATERIJALA S
KASNOANTIČKOG/RANOSREDNJOVJEKOVNOG GROBLJA U NOVIGRADU (ISTRA)
Sažetak
U radu je obrađen ljudski osteološki materijal s kasnoantnićkog i
ranosrednjovjekovnog groblja u Novigradu, čiji skromni arheolo{ki nalazi
upu}uju da je donje datacijske težište u 5. ili najkasnije 6. stoljeću po
Kristu. Cilja rada bila je antropološko-osteološka analiza koja će
pružiti prve, skromne podatke, o biološkim osobinama ljudi koji su
nastavali područje Istre u ovom povijesnom periodu. Osnovni dojam o
populaciji je veliki udio dječje populacije, relativno niža starost
ženskog dijela populacije u usporedbi s vrijednostima s drugih groblja,
slaba i neadekvatan prehrana koja je uzrokovala dio patoloških promjena,
te teški fizički rad i prenaprezanje.
Introduction
In 1991, Archaeological Museum of Istria carried out a rescue
excavation in the southwestern part of old Novigrad's center. During the
excavation, 12 scattered graves, dated to the Late Roman/Early Medieval
period, were exposed. All of them, except grave no. 4, contained human
skeletal remains accompanied by only a few, if any, grave goods (1).
Description, typology and list of artifacts found in graves are based
on archaeological documentation. There are two groups of burials
concerning body orientation. The first, bigger group, oriented in
east-west direction, with the head to the west, is located in the NW side
of the examined area. Burial types present in this group are inhumations
in stone cysts and simple inhumations. The second group are peripheral
burials with simple inhumations, with bodies laid down in north-south
direction (1).
Types of inhumation follow Ujčić (1):
- Type I – graves with stone-built construction, a frequent type in
Late Roman Istria, dating from the 3rd to the 5th century;
- Type II – inhumation in stone cysts, a type very frequent on Late
Roman and Early Medieval cemeteries, and
- Type III – simple inhumation.
The most common small finds are gray, brown and black fragments of
coarse, wheel-made jars with round bodies, sometimes decorated with simple
wavy or parallel-line incisions. All of the pottery was scattered above
the deceased or around him, and probably was not deposited as a part of
the funeral ritual (1).
The recovered burials are part of a bigger cemetery, most of which was
destroyed. For burials terminus post quem was established
archaeologically as 5th or 6th century A.D.(1).
The aim of this work was bioarchaeological analysis of human skeletal
remains. Results of this analysis provide information on population
structure, health, nutrition and physical stress of the ancient
inhabitants of Novigrad. Results from Novigrad cemetery were further
compared with results from analyses of four roughly contemporaneous Late
Roman populations in continental Croatia
[which does not share a common history with
Istria]: Štrbinci (Roman Certissia)
near Đakovo, »Eastern necropolis« in Osijek (Roman Mursa), Zmajevac
and Vinkovci (Roman Cibalae). All four sites are located in Eastern
Slavonia and dated to 4th century A.D.(2).
Material and Methods
The analyzed sample consisted of 13 individuals from 12 graves. All of
the burials were single inhumations, except for graves no. 7 (two
females), no. 10 (two subadults) and no. 4 which contained animal bones
only. Bone preservation varied from good to excellent. Completeness of the
individual skeletons varied, but the majority was fairly complete, missing
only few bones.
Detailed analysis of each individual was carried out using Standards
for data collection from human skeletal remains3. It included
determination of sex, age at the time of death, dental status,
reconstruction of body height, and detailed description of pathological
changes on bones and joint surfaces acquired during lifetime. Results of
individual analyses were combined to provide limited data on demography,
health and disease of the ancient inhabitants of Novigrad.
Determination of the sex was based on morphological differences of
pubic sym-physis4 and morphology of the skull5,6. Adult age at death was
determined using the pubic symphysis morphology7, the auricular surface
morphology8, sternal rib end changes9,10 and cranial suture clo-sure11.
Age at death for subadults was determined using epiphyseal fusion12,13,
dental eruption criteria14, and long bones length15,12. Detailed dental
inventory was completed for each skeleton. All teeth were coded for their
presence or absence, as well as for presence of carious lesions and
alveolar abscesses. Presence of dental calculus and enamel hypoplasia was
also scored. Each skeleton was examined for the evidence of possible
pathology. For the identification of pathological changes, criteria by
Ortner and Putchar16 and Mann and Murphy17 were used.
Results
Demography
The analyzed sample consists of 13 individuals, 8 adults and 5
subadults (under 15 years of age). Age and sex distribution of skeletons
from Novigrad is given in Table 1.
TABLE 1
SEX AND AGE AT DEATH IN THE NOVIGRAD SAMPLE
Burial |
Sex |
Age |
1 |
M |
35–49 |
2 |
S |
0–5 |
3 |
M |
20–34 |
5 |
S |
0–5 |
6 |
S |
0–5 |
7a |
F |
35–49 |
7b |
F |
15–20 |
8 |
M |
35–49 |
9 |
M |
35–49 |
10a |
S |
0–5 |
10b |
S |
0–5 |
11 |
F |
35–49 |
12 |
F |
15–20 |
M = male; F = female; S = subadult
The ratio males:females:subadults is 1:1:1.25 stands out from normal
sex ratio found in archaeological populations, where it is 1:1:118.
Relatively high proportion of subadults may simply be a consequence of
small sample size, which is not representative of the population or the
fact that the analyzed individuals were recovered from the lowest layers
of destroyed cemetery. Subadults are usually underrepresented in sample
from cemeteries because their burials tend to be shallow, their bones are
fragile and sometimes their burial rituals differ from those of the
adults.
The average age at death for adult females is 29.8 years and for adult
males 38.3. The average age at the death for adult males is comparable to
other contemporary Late Roman populations in Croatia (Table 2), while the
average age at death for females is lower than in any other cemetery. The
number of females and males in the present sample is low, and as such
might not be representative.
TABLE 2
AGE AT DEATH IN NOVIGRAD AND OTHER CONTEMPORARY LATE ROMAN POPULATIONS
(BASED ON THE ADULTS ONLY)
|
Adult males |
Adult females |
Reference |
Age |
N |
Age |
N |
Štrbinci |
39.3 |
9 |
35.5 |
8 |
Šlaus, 2002 |
Mursa |
33.8 |
9 |
36.1 |
12 |
Šlaus, 2002 |
Zmajevac |
40.5 |
14 |
43.1 |
14 |
Šlaus, 2002 |
Vinkovci |
36.5 |
13 |
39.4 |
12 |
Šlaus, 2002 |
Novigrad |
38.3 |
4 |
29.8 |
4 |
this study |
Nutritional stress
Skeletal evidence of nutritional stress collected from the analyzed
sample included cribra orbitalia and ectocranial porosity. These changes
are connected with acute stress and malnutrition, deficiency of vitamin A,
D and C, or anemia19 (Table 3).
TABLE 3
FREQUENCY OF CRIBRA ORBITALIA IN THE WHOLE SAMPLE
|
Cribra orbitalia (%) |
Štrbinci |
18.7 |
Mursa |
9.1 |
Zmajevac |
21.7 |
Vinkovci |
33.3 |
Novigrad |
66.6 |
Ectocranial porosity is characterized by tiny pits on the outer vault,
most commonly on parietals, but also on occipital and frontal bone near
bregma. For ectocranial porosity it is important that pitting is never
accompanied by thickening of the bone. This change is associated with
acute and severe malnutrition19,17. The ectocranial porosity in Novigrad
was present in 2 out of 5 individuals or 40% of the analyzed sample. This
cannot be compared to other contemporary Late Roman populations in
Croatia, since comparative information has not been published.
[Ed. Such information is not comparable since Istria
was not part of Croatia, nor had a common history with modern Croatia
prior 20th century.]
Cribra orbitalia appears as holes on the roof of the orbits. It is
caused by iron deficiency, malnutrition, infectious disease, scurvy or
various anemias20. In the Novigrad sample cribra orbitalia is present in
66.6% of the sample. This high frequency, if compared to other
contemporary populations in Croatia, suggests that the ancient inhabitants
of Novigrad experienced considerable subadult stress. High level of
metabolic stress in childhood can be explained by the high frequency of
subadults in the analyzed sample. High lesion frequency is associated with
infancy and childhood and is consistent with the pattern observed in other
skeletal series20.
Physical stress
Markers that were analyzed to evaluate physical stress in the sample
are: vertebral degenerative changes, incidence of Schmorl's nodes in
vertebral bodies and benign cortical defects (Tables 4 and 5).
TABLE 4
FREQUENCY OF VERTEBRAL DEGENERATIVE CHANGES IN ADULTS
|
Vertebral degenerative changes (%) |
Both sexes |
Males |
Females |
Štrbinci |
6.1 |
6.9 |
4.6. |
Mursa |
11.0 |
15.5 |
6.1 |
Zmajevac |
7.8 |
10.1 |
5.4 |
Vinkovci |
8.6 |
7.1 |
11.2 |
Novigrad |
45.8 |
54.2 |
41.6 |
TABLE 5
FREQUENCY OF SCHMORL'S NODES IN ADULTS
|
Schmorl's nodes (%) |
Both sexes |
Males |
Females |
Štrbinci |
8.8 |
4.9 |
14.3 |
Mursa |
15.9 |
29.7 |
0.0 |
Zmajevac |
15.8 |
19.0 |
12.6 |
Vinkovci |
14.5 |
13.4 |
16.5 |
Novigrad |
21.9 |
19.2 |
23.4 |
Vertebral degenerative changes are the most common changes in
archaeological and contemporary populations. For the Novigrad sample,
frequency of vertebral changes is 45.8% of the adult individuals (Table
4). Compared to values from other sites, this high value, slightly higher
in males (54.2%), suggests that several of the analyzed individuals were
exposed to heavy physical labor during their adulthood.
Schmorl's nodes are small depressions in thoracic and lumbar vertebrae
and are very common in all populations. Their appearance is associated
with heavy physical stress.
In the analyzed sample, frequency in females is slightly higher (23.4%)
then in males (19.2%). The overall frequency of Schmorl's nodes in the
sample is 21.9%, which is slightly higher then at other sites (Table 5).
Benign cortical defects, when in adults, are one of the markers of
physical stress. Defects appear as grooves or furrows at ligamentous or
tendinous attachment sites for muscles such as pectoralis major, teres
major, or biceps brachii. In younger individuals, these changes represent
normal variants in growing bone17,21. The type of benign cortical defect
present is Novigrad sample is rhomboid fossa, which appears as a
roughened, pitted depression, or a smooth, raised eminence on the inferior
surface of the clavicle for attachment of the costoclavicular ligament.
Etiology of rhomboid fossa is still unknown, but it may be associated with
strenuous activity of the pectoral girdle (17).
For the Novigrad sample, frequency of rhomboid fossa is 10.0%, is lower
then the frequency for Štrbinci, 33.3%.
Pathological conditions
The individual from grave 11 has spondylolysis on fifth lumbar
vertebra. Spondylolysis is separation of vertebral body from the posterior
vertebral arch. Etiology of spondylolysis is still unresolved, but genetic
and congenital factors as well as trauma to the lower back must be
considered21.
An adult female skeleton from grave 7a has congenital hip dislocation.
Aceta-bulum is shallow and porotic, permitting the femoral head to slip
and form a secondary joint16,17. Unfortunately, femora of this individual
are missing, which prevented us from examining the influence on the joint.
Only one case of infectious disease was observed. The individual from
grave no. 9 shows evidence of spine tuberculosis. Tuberculosis affected
three vertebrae (L3–L5), completely destroying the body of L4, which
collapsed and fused to the neighboring vertebrae.
Conclusion
The size of the analyzed sample from Novigrad cemetery, dated to the
Late Roman and/or Early Medieval period is too small to be considered
representative of the whole population. As a consequence, results of our
analysis should be taken with caution.
Despite that they provide limited data on demography, health and
disease of the ancient inhabitants of Novigrad, which is valuable because
no other bioarchaeolo-gical information is available from the Late Roman
and Early Medieval period in Istria.
Results show unusually high proportion of subadults buried and further,
indicating a relatively low average age at death for females. These finds
must be followed up in the future research.
High frequency of nutritional stress, especially cribra orbitalia, is
evidence of stress during childhood. Reconstruction of life style from
skeletal indicators of physical stress suggests that several of the
analyzed individuals were exposed to heavy physical labor during their
adulthood.
A single observed case of spine tuberculosis, can tell us little about
frequency of this disease in the general population.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology
of the Republic of Croatia (project 0196004).
REFERENCES
- Ujčić, Ž., Izdanja HAD-a, 18 (1997) 217.
- Šlaus, M.: The bioarchaeology of continental Croatia: An analysis of
human skeletal remains from the Prehistoric to post-Medieval periods.
(BAR International Series 1021, Oxford, 2002).
- Buikstra, J., D. Ubelaker: Standards for data collection from human
skeletal remains. (Arkansas Archaeological Survey, Fayetteville, 1994).
- Phenice, T., Am.J. Phys., Anthropol., 8 (1969) 679.
- Wea, J. Hum. Evol., 9 (1980) 517.
- Schwartz, J. H.: Skeleton keys. (Oxford University Press, Oxford,
1995).
- Meindl, R. S., C. O. Lovejoy, R. P. Mensforth, R. A. Walker, Am. J.
Phys. Anthropol., 68 (1985) 29. -
- Lovejoy, C. O., R. S. Meindl, T. R. Pryz-Beck, R. P. Mensforth, Am.
J. Phys. Anthropol., 68 (1985) 15.
- Išcan, M. Y., S. R. Loth, R. K. Wright, J. Forensic Sci., 30 (1984)
853.
- Išcan, M. Y., S. R. Loth, R K. Wright, J. Forensic Sci., 29 (1985)
1094.
- Meindl, R S., C. O. Lovejoy, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol, 68 (1985) 57.
- Uberlaker D. H., J.
Forensic
Sci., 32 (1987) 1254.
Redfield, A., Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 33
(1970) 207.
Uberlaker, D. H.: Human skeletal remains. (Taraxacum
Press, Washington, 1989).
Bass, W. M.: Human osteology. (Missouri
Archaeological Society, Missouri, 1981).
Ortner, D., W. Putschar: Identification
of pathological conditions in human skeletal remains. (Smithsonian
University Press, Washington, 1985).
Mann, W. R, P S. Murphy: Regional atlas of bone
disease. (Charles C. Thomas Springfield Illinois 1990).
Šlaus, M.,
Staro, hrvatska prosvjeta, 25 (1988) 81.
Martin, D. L., A. H.
Goodman, G. J. Armelagos, Skeletal pathologies as indicators of quality
and quantity of diet. In: Gilbert, R. I., J. H. Mielke (Eds.): The
analysis of Prehistoric diets. (Academic Press, Orlando, 1985).
Stuart-Macadam, P, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 66 (1985) 391.
Larsen,
C. S.: Bioarchaeology. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1997).
P. Rajić
Institute for Anthropological Research, Amruševa 8, 10000 Zagreb,
Croatia
Source:
- Coll. Antropol. 27 (2003) 2:
803–808; UDC 572.781:904"65"(497.5).
Original scientific paper -
hrcak.srce.hr/file/44315
and
http://hrcak.srce.hr/index.php?show=clanak&id_clanak_jezik=44315&lang=en
|
Main
Menu
Created:
Wednesday, April 08,
2009; Last Updated:
Tuesday, December 21, 2021
Copyright © 1998
IstriaNet.org, USA
|
|